• About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • e-Paper
  • Terms Of Service
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • Login
The Mast Logo
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Login
  • e-Paper
  • Politics
  • Courts & Crime
  • Biz
  • Health
    Cholera

    Cholera deaths reach 41 as cases soar

    Cholera

    Cholera cases hit 1,314 as death toll rises to 27

    Tobacco cartels targeting kids, parents warned

    Tobacco cartels targeting kids, parents warned

    Experts call for ebola preparedness

     Electoral defeat a mental health issue – NGO

  • Tech
    Zambia makes strides towards cyber security   

    Zambia makes strides towards cyber security  

    Texas becomes first state to ban DeepSeek, Rednote on government devices after fury over China-backed apps

    Texas becomes first state to ban DeepSeek, Rednote on government devices after fury over China-backed apps

    PARALYSED MAN FLIES VIRTUAL DRONE USING BRAIN IMPLANT.

  • Sports
  • World
  • Columnists
  • Opinion
  • Features
  • Today’s
  • Home
    • Login
  • e-Paper
  • Politics
  • Courts & Crime
  • Biz
  • Health
    Cholera

    Cholera deaths reach 41 as cases soar

    Cholera

    Cholera cases hit 1,314 as death toll rises to 27

    Tobacco cartels targeting kids, parents warned

    Tobacco cartels targeting kids, parents warned

    Experts call for ebola preparedness

     Electoral defeat a mental health issue – NGO

  • Tech
    Zambia makes strides towards cyber security   

    Zambia makes strides towards cyber security  

    Texas becomes first state to ban DeepSeek, Rednote on government devices after fury over China-backed apps

    Texas becomes first state to ban DeepSeek, Rednote on government devices after fury over China-backed apps

    PARALYSED MAN FLIES VIRTUAL DRONE USING BRAIN IMPLANT.

  • Sports
  • World
  • Columnists
  • Opinion
  • Features
  • Today’s
No Result
View All Result
The Mast Logo
No Result
View All Result
Home Features

Swept off the pavement: Can Lusaka be clean without being cruel?

Operation Clear Path has public applause and the law on its side. Whether it also has fairness, dignity and the spirit of the Constitution on its side is a question Lusaka can no longer avoid.

November 18, 2026
in Features
Mehluli Malisa Batakathi

Mehluli Malisa Batakathi

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Swept off the pavement: Can Lusaka be clean without being cruel?

Operation Clear Path has public applause and the law on its side. Whether it also has fairness, dignity and the spirit of the Constitution on its side is a question Lusaka can no longer avoid.

By Mehluli Malisa Batakathi

ON 29 September, as the Lusaka City Council’s deadline expired, Natasha stood on Simon Mwewa Road, holding an eviction notice, and asked the question thousands of traders were asking: “Where do they want us to go?” She had sold her wares on that same patch of pavement for more than a decade, and, she told reporters, that patch had kept her children in school.

Seven weeks on, her question still hangs in the air. Since Mayor Chitambala Mwewa took office after the August elections, Operation Clear Path has swept vendors from the Central Business District and arterial roads, and has rolled, often in the early hours, into Kamwala, where more than 500 structures in the Blue Tent area and over 360 stalls beneath the flyover bridge have been reduced to splintered timber and torn tarpaulin. Many residents applaud, understandably so; the pavements can be walked again, the drains can breathe, and with cholera looming with the rains, the capital at last looks properly governed.

Yet applause is not an argument, and it must not drown out the harder questions of whether Lusaka can become orderly without punishing the poor for being poor, and whether the Council, in its haste, has kept faith with the very laws it invokes.

An old problem in a new coat

During the cholera emergency of 2017 and 2018, police and paramilitary officers razed makeshift stalls across the city, only for the vendors to drift back once the crisis had passed, because the poverty and joblessness that drove them onto the pavements had never gone anywhere.

Politics has kept this wheel turning; after all vendors are voters, so successive governments have tolerated street trading in campaign season and cracked down once the ballots were counted. Nor does the Council come to this debate with spotless hands, for Kamwala traders insist that it collected levies from the very structures it now condemns as illegal, a point the lawyer Simon Mulenga Mwila has pressed publicly.

However, the current government deserves credit for confronting a problem its predecessors managed with a wink, but confronting is not solving. This campaign will be defined less by its resolve than by its method.

What the two laws actually say

On 23 September, Town Clerk Oliver Muuka issued an “official notification to all street vendors,” ordering them to vacate the streets by 29 September, on pain of losing their trading spaces. The notice was grounded in the Markets and Bus Stations Act No. 7 of 2007 and Statutory Instrument No. 12 of 2018, neither of which says quite what the Council’s bulldozers imply.

Begin with the Statutory Instrument, which does only one thing: it replaces a schedule of fines. Item 45 penalises selling goods “in an undesignated place or street” with a fine of 1,666.67 fee units, about K667 at today’s value of forty ngwee per unit; item 46 punishes the buyer; and items 9 and 15 penalise street trading without the Council’s “permission,” revealing a regime of regulated permission rather than absolute prohibition. It says nothing about notice, confers no power to demolish, and authorises no one to seize so much as a tomato. Its remedy is a fine, and a fine is something a court imposes.

The Act tells a strikingly similar story, as it contains no general ban on street trading. Section 33 allows regulations and by-laws, and section 33(4) makes their breach punishable “on conviction,” again before a magistrate. Its only demolition power is narrow, limited to market buildings that both depart from approved plans and endanger public health or safety. Section 8, governing the demolition or relocation of a market, requires the Council to act “in consultation with the Minister” and to notify in writing whoever manages the market, yet it prescribes no period and speaks of markets established under the Act, not tarpaulin stalls on a road reserve. Inspectors under sections 10 and 11 may enter and examine, but nowhere may they confiscate.

Two conclusions follow. First, these instruments support fines and prosecutions, not summary demolitions, midnight clearances or the confiscation of stock; if the Council draws those powers from other legislation, it has not said so. Second, because neither instrument sets a notice period, the six days allowed were an administrative choice, to be assessed under the settled principles of administrative law, which require that a person facing the loss of a livelihood receive adequate notice, a genuine hearing and intelligible reasons.

There is a quiet irony here. The model management lease in the Act’s own Schedule allows a council and a market board to part ways only on “three (3) calendar months’ notice, in writing.” Parliament thought ninety days’ fair warning between two public bodies; the Council thought six days enough for a mother who had traded on the same corner for ten years.

The Act even contains a humane alternative within its pages. Section 7 empowers a council, on its own motion or on application, to designate any place as a market street for a specified period, and Section 12 allows it to licence hawkers and pedlars to trade there. What has been missing is the will to use them.

Then there is the use of force. Stalls have fallen under cover of darkness, and on 9 November, army special forces joined the clean-up in Kamwala. Neither instrument contemplates soldiers, and enforcement that resembles a military operation sends an unmistakable message about who the city is for.

The Constitution after 2016

Honesty requires acknowledging the law’s limits. The Bill of Rights contains no enforceable right to a livelihood, and the old Directive Principles, which asked the State to “endeavour to create conditions under which all citizens shall be able to secure adequate means of livelihood,” were neither justiciable nor enforceable and were repealed in 2016. A vendor cannot sue the Council simply for lost income.

That is not the end of the matter. Article 8 now enshrines human dignity, equity and social justice among the national values, and Article 9 declares that they “shall apply” to the “development and implementation of State policy,” which includes enforcement. Article 10 commits government to rewarding “individual initiative and self-reliance,” the very virtue a pavement trader practises daily. Article 16 forbids the compulsory taking of property except under an Act of Parliament, a guarantee that bites once we see that neither instrument authorises seizure. Article 11 promises the protection of the law. Courts from Bombay, in Olga Tellis (1985), to Johannesburg, in South African Informal Traders Forum (2014), have refused to let public order be purchased at the price of a fair hearing.

A gentler road to the same destination

The government’s own figures suggest such a road exists. On 3 November, Local Government Minister Gift Sialubalo told Parliament that Lusaka has more than 14,000 trading spaces across 34 markets, of which only 405 are allocated, despite roughly 8,000 registered vendors. He urged councils to act “lawfully, professionally, consistently and humanely.” If thousands of stands lie empty while traders are hounded from the roads, the problem is not a shortage of space but a failure to connect people to it. The deeper challenge is even larger: the Zambia Institute of Architects estimates Lusaka’s informal traders at 250,000 to 350,000.

A rights-centred approach would keep the destination but change the route. It would allocate first and enforce second, assigning each displaced trader a named stand before any deadline expires; give notice measured in weeks, with written reasons and a channel of appeal; use section 7 to designate market streets with water and toilets; price stands within reach of the poor; collect levies only through the Council, as item 54 of the Statutory Instrument requires; and prosecute offenders, as the law intends, rather than destroy their livelihoods. None of this is soft on disorder, for a trader who has somewhere better to go will go there.

The verdict belongs to the reader

Nobody should romanticise blocked pavements or the cholera that feeds on them, and Lusaka has every right to clean streets. The question is whether order can be built on the backs of people whose only offence is trying to feed their families.

The Act the Council invokes is not silent on process, even where it is silent on time. It requires that a market be moved only “in consultation with the Minister” and after written notice; it punishes breaches of its by-laws only “on conviction”; it requires that a market street be announced in the Gazette and the press; and it measures fair warning, in its own model lease, in calendar months rather than working days. Together, these provisions describe a law that expects deliberation, paper and patience, not deadlines that expire before a trader has found her next stand. A crackdown that reaches beyond its own laws and past the values the Constitution says must guide them may win the street and still lose the argument. It is for the reader to judge whether six days’ notice, midnight demolitions and soldiers in Kamwala are what a just city looks like. My own view is that Lusaka can have clean streets and still keep faith with the poor, and that Natasha’s question deserves an honest answer before the next notice goes up.

Mehluli Malisa Batakathi is a Constitutional Lawyer and Lecturer, and writes “The Public Interest” in his personal capacity as a civic education initiative.

Previous Post

Qualcomm Celebrates Make in Africa Finale & Announces Social Impact Fund Winner

Next Post

FANS INSPIRED MY HEROICS

Next Post
FANS INSPIRED MY HEROICS

FANS INSPIRED MY HEROICS

Please login to join discussion

Join Us Today

  • 334.9K
    Followers
    334.9K
    Followers
  • Click To Join
    Subscribers
    Click To Join
    Subscribers
  • 7K
    Followers
    7K
    Followers
The Mast Newspaper

Bringing you breaking news, in-depth stories, and exclusive content at lightning speed.

Follow Us

  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • e-Paper
  • Terms Of Service

© 2025 Published by Mast Media Limited

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • Login
  • e-Paper
  • Politics
  • Courts & Crime
  • Biz
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Sports
  • World
  • Columnists
  • Opinion
  • Features
  • Today’s

© 2025 Published by Mast Media Limited

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.