ARTICLE 22
Retirement in ‘national interest’: What have public workers not done?
EVERY Zambian, irrespective of tribal or political affiliation, has an equal stake in the republic and consequently the right to equal treatment regarding employment in the public service. Apparently, this was the UPND position in opposition. But since acquiring power five years ago, several civil servants were reportedly ‘dumped’ at Cabinet Office and the strategy appears to have evolved into ‘retirement in national interest’.
Following the last disputed elections, some public workers have been retired ‘in national interest’ without charge or being heard. The latest was Dr Paul Kasalwe Chibwe, the Resident Doctors Association of Zambia (RDAZ) president, who was reportedly just handed a letter, without explanation, and had done nothing to warrant dismissal other than promoting doctor’s welfare. Last month, police spokesperson Godfrey Chilabi also confirmed being retired but couldn’t elaborate. Apparently, rather than doing something, there is something public workers haven’t done.
Why not disclose the ‘national interest’ being protected?
UPND National Youth Chairperson Gilbert Liswaniso was the first to be quoted saying government had started dismissing civil servants perceived to be against the Hichilema administration and that the purge would continue because there were people working with the opposition to frustrate government. Liswaniso was further quoted that more civil servants would be ‘retired in national interest’ for working with the opposition (Mast Newspaper, 19 October). In response, Reverend Given Katuta demanded transparency and that those affected be listed.
But UPND National Management Committee member Phinias Kalenga later said the purge wasn’t targeted at opposition sympathisers – that those retired were a liability who couldn’t deliver the Grow Zambia Agenda and therefore needed to make way for others (Mast Newspaper, 21 October).
Earlier, President Hichilema had threatened to be ruthless – that he would no longer tolerate civil servants that delay and frustrate government projects (Daily Nation, 21 October). The day before, the president had said he initially thought civil servants knew what to do and just didn’t want to, until discovering that they didn’t know what to do. And in his address to parliament, President Hichilema talked of a result oriented civil service but, rather surprisingly, said nothing about a professional or merit based public service.
Clearly, these are not isolated personal views but representative of the party’s position. But then, is the grievance sabotage, incompetence or not supporting the ruling party? Or could it be the cost of maintaining those allegedly ‘dumped’ at Cabinet Office on payroll? Apparently, no one has cited a specific failing. And if performance be the issue, why not show how those being retired have underperformed and how their peers have excelled. There should be no difficulty demonstrating what ‘national interest’ is threatened. Dating back to the Lungu era, however, the overarching goal has ostensibly been to reward party loyalists and place them in strategic positions.
How can ‘bosses’ deliver if juniors haven’t?
Despite initiating most government policies and programmes, civil servants are primarily implementers. If they have failed to deliver, therefore, it begs the question what policies, programmes or reforms has the leadership promulgated which they haven’t implemented. Simply put, public workers operate within frameworks created by the political leadership. While in Dubai, for instance, the president was still talking about undertaking business reforms. Can civil servants then be blamed for a sluggish business sector?
And how could it be that relatively lower staff underperform but their superiors – permanent secretaries and ministers, deliver. How, in fact, could the president himself have delivered, as we were told during the campaigns – that everything was kwenyu, if the civil service hasn’t? Paradoxically, even all presidential aides delivered as evidenced by their reappointment. Moreover, what about delivery structures like the Presidential Delivery Unit (PDU) and the Public Private Sector Dialogue Forum (PPDF) – what is their share of the blame? Besides, what has come of the purge that has been going on – has it also failed to deliver?
Where are the unions and service commissions?
The dismissals further raise questions for trade unions. It is astounding that unions which have been vocal on remote issues like Bill 7 can remain quiet while their members are threatened with job losses. It’s equally ironic that rather than the employer – service commissions, party officials can be the ones driving these dismissals.
Under article 185 of the Constitution, the power to appoint, discipline and terminate employment in the public service lies with service commissions. For instance, article 222 vests the power to ‘appoint, confirm, promote and hear appeals’ from civil servants in the Civil Service Commission. In what capacity then are ruling party officials ‘cleansing the public service’? And what is the position of service commissions on this usurpation of their power? The whole essence of establishing service commissions was to avoid precisely what we are witnessing – to ensure fairness in the recruitment, discipline and dismissal of public workers.
More importantly, what due process are the affected being subjected to? Like most have pointed out, it offends the rules of natural justice to condemn someone without hearing them. Besides, what about public workers and officials that openly canvassed support for the ruling party? Is partisanship then only when one supports or is perceived to support the opposition? Under article 173 of the Constitution, values governing the public service include merit as the basis for appointment and promotion and equal opportunities for appointment for all.
What kind of public service are we building?
Ultimately, the question is what kind of public service we want to build. Retiring or dismissing public workers without justifiable cause can only create a public service that is compromised. At the very least, these unguarded calls to purge public workers sow fear, suspicion and division. The public service and the civil service, in particular, is too important to be handled recklessly. According to Professor Muna Ndulo, the civil service is the bedrock of the governement, providing not only expert advise on the basis of which policy is deteremined but also the machinery for the execution of policy.
It is regrettable how the civil service has been politicised. Until the Lungu presidency, only political appointees were affected by election cycles or change of government. But we are also witnessing probably the highest number ever of partisan individuals being appointed permanent secretaries. In fact, partisanship during the last elections, particularly in favour of the ruling UPND, was so perverse that some have since been calling for permanent secretaries and district commissioners to be reclassified as politicians.
Equally concerning is the inability by those retiring others to empathize and be mindful of the ramifications of their decisions which may include destitution, health complications, marriage breakups, loss of confidence in the political system and premature deaths – including suicide. Unfortunately, some if not most of the victims, may have been falsely accused and denied the opportunity to vindicate themselves.
Where to for the public worker?
My advice to public workers is to always do the right thing and remain non-partisan. You are better of losing your job for doing the right thing. Remember, ‘superior orders’ is no defense and ‘there is no honour among thieves’.
The author is a lawyer and a citizen who wants the best for our country.
For comments and feedback: chris.mapani@gmail .com






