When politicians turn courts into battlefields
…The Judiciary in a democracy is the hardest working institution during politically and criminally manufactured conflicts that result in criminal charges
By Professor Munyonzwe Hamalengwa
IN any political democracy, the judiciary is put under intense pressure to resolve politically and criminally manufactured crises originating from contending political spheres, hemispheres and empires.
These contending entities then expect the judiciary to resolve the crises that they have created, leaving very little resources for the resolution of real problems that affect the majority of the people.
The contending entities are in fact using the judiciary for the continuation of their politics by other means.
If the contending parties don’t like decisions arrived at and pronounced by the judiciary, they then accuse the judiciary of being a captured institution that has no independence and autonomy.
What the contending parties really expect is for the judiciary to hand down decisions in their own favour irrespective of the dictates of the law and precedence.
In a perfect democratic world, the politically contending parties should be the first examples of models for abiding by the dictates of the constitution and the rule of law in order to avoid the very conflicts that end up in the hands of the judiciary.
The sad part in some instances is when the politically and criminally engineered crises result in generating intense social and political divisions within the judiciary, it tears the fabric of the judiciary that held this institution together leading to the loss of judicial reputation.
Segments of the contending political elites cherish it when the spotlight of alleged disrepute is now shone on the judiciary rather than on them who first caused the rivalry within the judiciary in the first place. These same segments when they lose the judicial war, begin to lament of persecution and judicial capture. Thou shalt know them by their deeds and words.
The judiciary also reveals it’ true character when it is put under pressure by the contending political elites. Is this a judiciary of any country that is seized of judicial independence and autonomy? Does this judiciary of any country take its oath to be beholden to the Constitution seriously and not to be beholden or to be at the direction of any person or entity?
The United States (US) is always a good example to study and leverage any study to the modus operandi of other systems, followed by the United Kingdom (UK). Contending political entities in other systems and countries also seek refuge when they are under pressure by summoning the aid of the US or UK or European Union (EU).
The judiciary in many countries also quote and use precedents from the US, UK and EU to buttress their predilections.
It is Richard Nixon who was so rebuffed by the Supreme Court that gave us hope that the judiciary was independent and autonomous when they told him through several rulings that nobody is above the law, not even the President.
Until Donald Trump came along, it was settled law and mantra around the world that nobody is above the law. Donald Trump came and got the judiciary to qualify the precedent that no-one is above the law.
Trump’s Supreme Court gave him and all presidents by extension, a zone of immunity and action in the pursuit of presidential jurisdiction. The jurisdiction is not defined. Trump’s Supreme Court messed up the law on “nobody is above the law” precedent that has been subsisting for centuries.
The English system through Lord Dening gave us a zone of judicial discretion where the judiciary could exercise and impose justice in the interests of equity and justice where ruling otherwise would render a visible injustice.
We now judge our judiciaries as to whether they would defer to the powerful and monied entities or they would render equity and justice in times of need.
The above schema sketched above, is abstract and it can only be studied on a case by case basis or country by country basis or judiciary on judiciary basis.
With this theoretical framework, now do your own study on the Zambian judiciary in a historical perspective.







